I am pretty harsh, I guess, but I think I would have been harsh in previous years too. For example, I would proooobably have ranked e.g. Captain Vorpatril's Alliance under No Award (but possibly not Cryoburn, which I also was not excessively fond of but which at least has interesting things to say about the economics of cryogenics). And definitely Wheel of Time, and probably Redshirts, which did actually win the Hugo, so we can see here that I may have a different opinion of what the Hugos should be doing than the average Hugo voter. :)