ase: Book icon (Books 2)
It's been brought to my attention I finally read the Shattered Earth trilogy last year, and didn't blog it. This came up when I mentioned my completely inexplicable desire to reread apocalypse fiction in this year when California is either burning or downwind of some of the worst wildfires on record.

...Okay, maybe this impulse has some explanation. Ahem.

For anyone who missed this on the first pass: fantasy / science fantasy trilogy, published 2015 - 2017, set on a world which is prone to geologic catastophes - volcanoes, earthquakes, tsunamis - that generate "fifth seasons": years without summer, or even clear skies. A second major worldbuilding chunk are the orogenes: people attuned to the earth's movements, who can deflect - or cause - some of these catastrophes. Orogenes are hated and feared by non-orogenes, perceived as another quake threat in lives organized around the inevitability of the next shake.

These come together in the first novel when a powerful orogene triggers a Fifth Season that could last centuries and wipe out humanity, just as the protagonist, Essun, learns her husband has discovered their young son is an orogene. Now the son is dead, and Essun's husband and daughter are missing. The Fifth Season packs in Essun backstory, general worldbuilding, and forward motion on Essun's road trip to find her husband and discover what he's done with her daughter.

The middle novel, The Obelisk Gate, alternates between Essun's adjustment to a community that is throwing out the book on orogene relations, and the travels of Nassun, Essun's daughter. Both learn more about using and mastering the orogenic powers they share.

The Stone Sky continues the physical and emotional journeys of Essun and Nassun, and adds the PoV of one of the enigmatic Stone Eaters, who retells the origins of the Seasons, as well as the deep-rooted (ha) whispers linked to hatred for orogenes. The fantasy / science fantasy vibe goes full Epic - Evil Father Earth turns out to be an intelligence (and not a happy one), there's a six-person trip through the earth's subsurface, powered by ~stone eater powers~, people throw around unimaginable power to do stuff with astral bodies - it's A Lot.




Okay, so, this is a really well written trilogy. It's dense and punchy and thoughtful. And it's also really angry. Look at the dedications: the first novel is "For all those who have to fight for the respect that everyone else is given without question." The second is "To those who have no choice but to prepare their children for the battlefield." The third goes out "To those who've survived: Breathe. That's it. Once more. Good. You're good. Even if you're not, you're alive. That is a victory."

If that's going to be an issue, well, know going in. Also know about the infanticide, the systemic use of violence to craft cages of habit and fear in people's minds, the various in-family killings, the extremely broken protagonists. (As I think [personal profile] skygiants put it, "I don't think Essun destroyed any cities at all this book! I'm so proud!" Ah, yes.)

The trilogy also bends toward fantasy, with titanic battles of will on not-quite-physical planes. It's not that the trilogy doesn't stick the landing. It just... it's the titanic battles of will landing. Which I am less excited about. I think I liked the second novel, which has a lot of community-building (and cycles of abuse stuff, because the entire trilogy is like that), more than I liked the third novel, which is a lot more interested in the epic fantasy stuff. I'm not sure it quite stuck the landing about destruction vs reform (some things can't be reformed, seems to be the argument; I'm still looking for a middle ground between Congress passes one measly bylaw and millions are killed because the system must be destroyed). On one level that seems to be where the trilogy's going: the climatic scene is a parent-child reunion. On another it's not. The climatic reunion is enmeshed with the two characters battling out the question of whose world-altering agenda is going to get implemented... and whose world-altering agenda is going to get set aside Because Family. The parts that come down to character work are really intense, the parts that are Epic are not as much my thing.

Random bonus: when I ran into the PulpĂ­ Geode and Naica Caves it made me think of Castrima-under.
ase: Book icon (Books 2)
My hours sleep / caffeinated drinks ratio is edging towards one. I feel fantastic, whenever my eyes uncross, but I dimly sense there's been some intellectual impact.

A Daughter of the Samurai (Etsu Sugimoto): Charming memoir of a Japanese immigrant to America. Picked this up after Lois Bujold mentioned it on the LMB mailing list. My first reflection was, "this delights in the way Hitty: Her First Hundred Years charms," which is less of a surprise when one considers they were both published in the 1920's. Sugimoto's memoir is written in a light-hearted storytelling style, recalling details of her experiences growing up on the western side of Japan, in what's now part of the Niigata Prefecture, as well as her stories of attending a missionary school in Tokyo, living in America as a wife and mother, and her temporary return to Japan after her husband's death.

The gentle tone glides past shadows of other stories: how did her husband die? How did Sugimoto support herself as a widow when she returned to America? After her husband's untimely death, it was expected she would return to Japan, but what moved her to move back to America? Sugimoto gracefully speaks of both sorrow and joy in her life, opening a window to another time and place.

The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms (N.K. Jemisin): Heiress to a minor kingdom is summoned by her grandfather and named one of the three candidates to be heir to his authority over all the kingdoms. Yeine has her wits and her mother's training to defend her against family politics and fettered gods with a plan to end their slavery.

Long, thematic but no explicit spoilers. )

I wasn't overwhelmed by the story or characters, but I was intrigued by the worldbuilding. The Hundred Thousand Kingdoms is the first in a trilogy; my lukewarm reaction to the first novel means I'll be waiting to see what other people think of the second and third novels before picking up anything else in the series, but if you're in the mood for "god of light and order is not equal to god of right" fiction, you'd probably like this.

The Privilege of the Sword (Ellen Kushner): Sequel to Swordspoint; briefly discussed previously. Duke Alec summons his sister's daughter from a country estate to settle a family break and have his niece trained as a swordsman. Niece Katherine expects a different sort of Season on the Hill in the wake of her uncle the Mad Duke. (I just love that phrase.)

Kushner is a charming stylist, but her plots are not nearly as intriguing. I liked Katherine, and I wanted to like the story, but I was disappointed that events didn't unroll to illuminate character or story very efficiently. For example, I can certainly make up a story about why Alec and Richard simply cannot be together despite their love, but I was sort of expecting the writer to explain how the characters got from Point A at the end of Swordspoint to Point B in Privilege of the Sword. I also hoped for some clever thoughts on Katherine taking up a role that was both traditionally male and beneath her class, but these didn't materialize. I can make inferences from her atraditional romance with Marcus, and her relationship with Artemisia, mediated through their mutual love for the "The Swordsman Whose Name Was Not Death", a novel-in-a-novel, but I was hoping for more explicit authorial intent and less Choose Your Own Adventure.

Dorothea Lange: A Life Beyond Limits (Linda Gordon): Picked off the library shelves on a whim. Dorothea Lange went down in history for photographing the iconic "Migrant Mother" picture of the Depression era, but also made significant contributions to national documentary photography and the San Francisco arts scene. Okay bio with significant weaknesses. )

Perhaps I'm judging on tone; perhaps I'm holding a female biographer to a double standard. However, this sort of writer construction from bare-bones accounts happens more than once: Lange and the FSA photographers, her thorny relationship with her mother, how her childhood polio might have progressed. It pushes the bounds of creative nonfiction right out of biography and into storytelling, a disappointing development. I'm not inclined to recommend this, unless you're looking for a generalist bio and can remain aware of its flaws.

A Madness of Angels (Kate Griffin): Matthew Swift comes back to life. Inspired by the American cover, I described this as "Castiel in London" for [personal profile] norabombay. The book is in that vein: high on concept and worldbuilding, a little low on characterization. Spoilers. )

I backslid and reread the back half of Cherryh's Regenesis. I stand by my earlier assertions there's a smashing good 300 page novel threading through some serious bloat.

Numbers game: 5 total finished. 5 new, 0.5 reread; 3.5 fiction, 2 nonfiction.

Profile

ase: Default icon (Default)
ase

July 2025

S M T W T F S
  123 45
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031  

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags